Bengals and 49ers trade(rejected)

Bengals get:
1st rounder
3rd Rounder
Brandon Jones 70 WR
Anthony Henry 78 CB
Nate Davis 64 QB

49ers get:
Carson Palmer 88 QB
5th Rounder

MainEvent wrote:Bengals get:
1st rounder
3rd Rounder
Brandon Jones 70 WR
Anthony Henry 78 CB
Nate Davis 64 QB

49ers get:
Carson Palmer 88 QB
5th Rounder

hmmm...I spose I accept

REJECTED..

Tyrants wrote:REJECTED..

Why?

TY you need to post why for rejections... on passes you can just post pass.

I think It was basicly that Im giving you a no name QB a bad WR and an old CB for a Franchise QB so it got rejected... even though one person even said i was giving up too much... It was a split decision basicly some thinking Im not giving enough, some too much a couple just right.

VYoung10 wrote:

Tyrants wrote:REJECTED..

Why?

too little impact players going back to Cincy... Palmer is franchise QB and franchise face... Davis likely does not have a lot of potential (despite what you may have heard, this is Madden, and fact is he's a 5th rounder)... Henry will retire soon... Jones is the 3rd or 4th best WR on Bengals... Palmer is still in his prime and a top 5 QB... Carson should definatly command more than that... once again protectign the league, if a new member were to take the Bengals would they really want a Bengals team led by Nate Davis and Jordan Palmer with no other star players coming in return?


^^^ Was the belief of most RC members. Two members however believed Main gave too much, go figure...

MainEvent wrote:TY you need to post why for rejections... on passes you can just post pass.

I think It was basicly that Im giving you a no name QB a bad WR and an old CB for a Franchise QB so it got rejected... even though one person even said i was giving up too much... It was a split decision basicly some thinking Im not giving enough, some too much a couple just right.

I told him I was going to post why- I just posted it...

can you say hypocrite?

big, u really have changed, man- you used to be cool and stuff, now you bitch at everything... I posted this on behalf of the RC- but for some reason you targeting me- I don't get it..

i really dont care anymore and dont wanna talk about anymore, but i think it is you who have changed my friend. If you recall, during the last attempt at a league, you thought my trade for Ed Reed was ridiculious and stated it many times over. I gave up Kiwi(85) S.Phillips(78) and A.Ross (81) all young studs with alot of potential, a far far far better package than what you just gave up under supposed stricter rules, for a player in the same age bracket rated slightly less.

Like i said, i dont wanna do this anymore, i thought we were just giving our opinions on things and talking them out. It may come across differently when reading it in print, but non of this actually makes me "mad" im just telling it how it is. Lets move on.

I haven't changed at all. But like you said, lets move on. Whats done is done. But Im going to remain consistant from here on out..