Texans/Lions Trade reworked

Texans get:

QB Matt Stafford 79

Lions get:

QB Matt Schaub 77
OLB Brian Cushing 78
TE Anthony Hill 68

The Texans accept.

I accept.

this deal is worse than the last one

I'll break it down. I AM NOT GIVING UP TOO MUCH.

Schaub is covered by Stafford, I lose Cushing but have a suitable replacement in June, and my 3rd string TE who would never play. This deal is fair, both teams have accepted.

i think the argument is that your not giving up enough

You will regret giving up Cush. He is a 78 with 84 speed and only 23 years old. June is 28 and a 68 overall, he isn't gonna get any better. Cushing could be a 85 by the end of the season.

Of course I will regret losing Cush, but I won't regret getting Stafford. You have to give something to get something.

bigc421 wrote:i think the argument is that your not giving up enough

Really?

This trade was Rejected by RC with the Reason being that is too much to give up for Matt Stafford.

Please re work the trade.

Can you guys make up your minds? I would like to get this deal done.

im not in the RC so i have no say, from most of the coments on the last trade, it sounded as if people felt you weren't giving up enough, then i saw mains said it was to much, which i dont get at all. Stafford was the first pick in the draft and is rated higher than Schaub already without playing a down yet. Stafford has the potential to be a 90+ qb.

I offered Kiwi Pat Williams, Tyrell Johsnon and T.Jackson for Stafford and he said he liked your deal better.

Well I thought he wasn't giving up enough. Thats why I rejected it. Stafford is a NUMBER ONE PICK QUARTERBACK with huge upside. Not only that he's probably the face of the franchise. Let me put it like this would you trade...

Matt Schaub
15th pick

for

1st pick


No you wouldn't.


I think a better deal would actually have the Texans giving up their '10 1st pick. I would approve that deal...

Matthew Stafford

for

Matt Schaub
Brian Cushing
1st Round Draft pick


That deal is fair...

tml_gogo wrote:I'll break it down. I AM NOT GIVING UP TOO MUCH.

Schaub is covered by Stafford, I lose Cushing but have a suitable replacement in June, and my 3rd string TE who would never play. This deal is fair, both teams have accepted.

I agree to this deal. it is an even deal.

Steelcrush7 wrote:

tml_gogo wrote:I'll break it down. I AM NOT GIVING UP TOO MUCH.

Schaub is covered by Stafford, I lose Cushing but have a suitable replacement in June, and my 3rd string TE who would never play. This deal is fair, both teams have accepted.

I agree to this deal. it is an even deal.

So this passes?

Passed